Rooms of Light

Emptiness: Lamas of other Tibetan schools (Al–Ap)

Teachers Al–Ap

Recorded teachings by lamas and teachers of the Gelug, Kagyu, Sakya, Jonang and Bön traditions, A–Z.

Rooms of Light gathers and organizes links to teachers, monastics, scholars, and their published resources. The teachings belong to the people and traditions linked here; this page offers no Dharma instruction of its own.

Lamas of other Tibetan schools

Dr. Alexander Berzin

Video 7 · Audio 18 · Texts 24

Teachers A–Z: every collection with Dr. Alexander Berzin

Gelug-trained translator and teacher (student of Tsenshap Serkong Rinpoche, Geshe Ngawang Dhargyey and the 14th Dalai Lama) · 1944–

Video

Gelug

Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika (7-part video seminar) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · June 2019 · English with Russian translation · 7 videos, total 9h 47m · FreeSeven-session video seminar on what is unique in Tsongkhapa's presentation of the Prasangika view of voidness, given in Moscow in June 2019.
Video 1 — 01/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (1:55:37) ↗ · Video 2 — 02/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (1:47:19) ↗ · Video 3 — 03/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (55:10) ↗ · Video 4 — 04/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (1:06:25) ↗ · Video 5 — 05/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (1:47:33) ↗ · Video 6 — 06/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (59:08) ↗ · Video 7 — 07/07 - Tsongkhapa's Unique View of Prasangika - EN-RU (1:16:09) ↗

Gelug

Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism (6-part video seminar) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · June 2015 · English with German translation · 6 videos, total 6h 58m · FreeSix-session video recording of the Vienna 2015 seminar on dependent arising and avoiding the extremes of nihilism and eternalism (transcript on studybuddhism.com as "Elaboration of Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Two Extremes").
Video 1 — 01/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (1:10:15) ↗ · Video 2 — 02/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (1:03:14) ↗ · Video 3 — 03/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (56:37) ↗ · Video 4 — 04/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (1:34:18) ↗ · Video 5 — 05/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (1:14:21) ↗ · Video 6 — 06/06 - Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Extremes of Nihilism and Eternalism - EN-DE (1:00:00) ↗

Gelug

How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" Experiencing the Four Noble Truths (11-part video seminar) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · November 2013 · English with Russian translation · 11 videos, total 11h 11m · FreeEleven-session video recording of the Moscow 2013 seminar on meditating on the voidness of the impossible "me" in the context of the four close placements of mindfulness and the four noble truths.
Video 1 — 01/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:16:27) ↗ · Video 2 — 02/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:41:39) ↗ · Video 3 — 03/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:02:49) ↗ · Video 4 — 04/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:25:34) ↗ · Video 5 — 05/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (50:07) ↗ · Video 6 — 06/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (35:06) ↗ · Video 7 — 07/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:02:33) ↗ · Video 8 — 08/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (1:09:15) ↗ · Video 9 — 09/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (52:30) ↗ · Video 10 — 10/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (41:21) ↗ · Video 11 — 11/11 - How to Meditate on the Voidness of the Impossible "Me" - Four Noble Truths / EN-RU (33:40) ↗

Gelug

How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth (10-part video seminar) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · September 2013 · English · 10 videos, total 10h 02m · FreeTen-session video recording of the Copenhagen 2013 seminar on cognition of voidness and liberation from samsara, through the four noble truths and twelve links.
Video 1 — 1/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (42:34) ↗ · Video 2 — 2/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (50:30) ↗ · Video 3 — 3/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:01:28) ↗ · Video 4 — 4/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:02:50) ↗ · Video 5 — 5/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:25:46) ↗ · Video 6 — 6/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:03:48) ↗ · Video 7 — 7/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (54:28) ↗ · Video 8 — 8/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:07:48) ↗ · Video 9 — 9/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (48:06) ↗ · Video 10 — 10/10 - How Cognition of Voidness Liberates Us from Uncontrollably Recurring Rebirth - EN (1:04:44) ↗

Gelug

Advice for Studying Voidness (video) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · April 2004 · English with Spanish translation · 2:15:06 · FreeFull-length video of Berzin's Morelia 2004 talk on how to approach the study of voidness.

Gelug

The Four Indian Tenet Systems on Voidness (Emptiness) (video) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism Archive (YouTube, official Berzin Archives channel) · April 2004 · English with Spanish translation · 2:40:24 · FreeFull-length video of Berzin's Morelia 2004 session presenting voidness in the four Indian Buddhist tenet systems.

Audio

Scholarly / cross-tradition

Emptiness and Dependent Arising ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Scholarly presentation of Tibetan Buddhist teachings, including Tsongkhapa’s perspective · Study Buddhism · Three-part English reading series with original seminar audio

Gelug

The Four Buddhist Tenet Systems Regarding the Two Truths ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeThree-part explanation of the two truths (superficial/conventional and deepest truth) as asserted in each Indian tenet system, culminating in Svatantrika and Prasangika, with original seminar audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Vaibhashika and Sautrantika: The Two Truths ↗ · Part 2 — Chittamatra: The Two Truths ↗ · Part 3 — Svatantrika and Prasangika: The Two Truths ↗

Gelug

Elaboration of "Dependent Arising: Avoiding the Two Extremes" ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeSix-part seminar on dependent arising and the extremes of absolutism and nihilism: what voidness negates, how conventional identity and valid knowability are accounted for, and the different levels of dependent arising. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Identifying Absolutism and Nihilism in Daily Life ↗ · Part 2 — What Emptiness or Voidness Negates ↗ · Part 3 — Accounting for the Conventional Identity of Things ↗ · Part 4 — Accounting for Something Being Validly Knowable ↗ · Part 5 — Validly Knowable Objects Are Not Self-Established ↗ · Part 6 — Different Types of Dependent Arising ↗ · Companion article — Dependent Arising: Avoiding Nihilism and Absolutism ↗

Gelug

Elaboration of “How Cognition of Emptiness Liberates Us” ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeTen-part seminar on unawareness of how the self exists, the twelve links and samsara, and cognition of the voidness of the coarse and subtle impossible "me"; includes a guided meditation. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — True Sufferings and the True Cause of Unhappiness ↗ · Part 2 — The True Causes of the Sufferings of Change and Samsara ↗ · Part 3 — True Stoppings, True Paths & First 3 of the 12 Links ↗ · Part 4 — Links 4 through 7 of the 12 Links of Dependent Arising ↗ · Part 5 — The Last 5 Links of the 12 Links of Dependent Arising ↗ · Part 6 — The 4 Noble Truths and 12 Links of Dependent Arising ↗ · Part 7 — The Coarse and Subtle Impossible “Me's” ↗ · Part 8 — Subtlest Impossible “Me” & Refutation of the Coarse Impossible “Me” ↗ · Part 9 — Meditation on the Emptiness of the Coarse Impossible “Me” ↗ · Part 10 — Mental Labeling and Purification ↗ · Shorter companion — How Cognition of Emptiness Liberates Us from Samsara (2 parts) ↗

Gelug

Overview of “Four Hundred Verse Treatise” – Dr. Berzin ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Root text by Aryadeva · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFour-part overview of Aryadeva's Four Hundred Verse Treatise, covering incorrect views of conventional truth and then the chapters refuting incorrect views of the deepest truth, voidness. With original seminar audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Incorrect Views of the Body ↗ · Part 2 — Incorrect Views of the Conventional Truth of Things ↗ · Part 3 — Background to Aryadeva's Chapters on Emptiness ↗ · Part 4 — Incorrect Views of the Deepest Truth of Things ↗ · Summary of "Four Hundred Verse Treatise" – Dr. Berzin ↗ · Root text — Four Hundred Verse Treatise (tr. Berzin) ↗

Gelug

Advice for Studying Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeSeminar talk on how to approach the study of voidness without fear, the merit, concentration and motivation it requires, and how to progress through the tenet systems. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.

Gelug

Commentary on “The Heart Sutra” – Dr. Berzin ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Root text by The Heart Sutra (Prajnaparamita) · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFour-part commentary on the Heart Sutra: Avalokiteshvara's teaching, "form is emptiness, emptiness is form," and the voidness of the aggregates, the twelve links and the four noble truths, with the original seminar audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Avalokiteshvara Expounding the Sutra ↗ · Part 2 — Form Is Emptiness, Emptiness Is Form ↗ · Part 3 — Emptiness of Cause and Effect and the Five Aggregates ↗ · Part 4 — Emptiness of the Twelve Links and the Four Noble Truths ↗ · Text — The Heart Sutra (Berzin translation, with recitation audio) ↗

Gelug

Incorrect Consideration and Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeSeven-part seminar on the four incorrect considerations (static, happy, clean, self) and on the voidness of persons and phenomena in relation to them. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Projections ↗ · Part 2 — Nonstatic Phenomena as Static ↗ · Part 3 — Suffering as Happiness and Unclean as Clean ↗ · Part 4 — What Is Not Self as Self ↗ · Part 5 — Doctrinally Based Grasping for the Self of a Person ↗ · Part 6 — Automatically Arising Grasping for the Self of a Person ↗ · Part 7 — Emptiness of All Phenomena ↗

Gelug

Main Points of Self-Voidness and Other-Voidness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFive-part seminar explaining self-voidness and other-voidness (rangtong/shentong) in relation to the four noble truths, how the tenet systems differ, and other-voidness as clear-light mind, from a Gelug standpoint. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Self-Voidness & Other-Voidness in the Four Noble Truths ↗ · Part 2 — Diversity of Views of Self-Voidness & Other-Voidness in the Tenet Systems ↗ · Part 3 — Doctrinally Based & Automatically Arising Impossible “Me” ↗ · Part 4 — Other-Voidness: Clear Light Mind or Rigpa ↗ · Part 5 — Truly Established Existence in the Tenet Systems ↗

Gelug

Negation Phenomena: How to Focus on Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFour-part seminar on negation phenomena as presented in the Jetsunpa textbooks, and on voidness as a non-implicative negation in the focus of meditation in each tenet system. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Negations and Affirmations ↗ · Part 2 — Exclusions ↗ · Part 3 — Categories and Implicative & Non-Implicative Negations ↗ · Part 4 — Focus on Emptiness According to the Tenet Systems ↗

Gelug

Refuting the False “Me” Experiencing the Four Noble Truths ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeTen-part seminar on identifying and refuting the coarse and subtle false "me" through the four close placements of mindfulness, the "neither one nor many" reasoning and voidness as a negation phenomenon; ends with a meditation. With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — Four Placements of Close Mindfulness & Four Noble Truths ↗ · Part 2 — The Coarse False “Me” of the Non-Buddhist Indian Systems ↗ · Part 3 — The Subtle False “Me” Refuted by All Buddhist Tenets ↗ · Part 4 — The Subtle False “Me” Refuted Only by Gelug Prasangika ↗ · Part 5 — Review of the Three Levels of a False “Me” ↗ · Part 6 — The Logic for Refuting the False “Me” ↗ · Part 7 — The Refutation “Neither One nor Many” ↗ · Part 8 — Emptiness as a Negation Phenomenon ↗ · Part 9 — Clarification of Questions on Emptiness ↗ · Part 10 — Meditation on the Emptiness of the False “Me” ↗

Gelug

The Emptiness of the False “Me” ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFour-part seminar on the conventional "me" as an imputation on the aggregates, dependent arising in terms of mental labeling, and the absence of anything findable establishing "me". With original audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — The Context for Understanding Emptiness ↗ · Part 2 — The Conventional “Me”: An Imputation on the 5 Aggregates ↗ · Part 3 — Dependent Arising in Terms of Mental Labeling ↗ · Part 4 — Nothing Findable Establishing “Me” as “Me” ↗

Gelug

Shamatha & Vipashyana Sections of "Lam-rim chen-mo" – audio course, Sections 4–10 (Vipashyana) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Root text by Je Tsongkhapa · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeStreaming audio from Dr. Berzin's weekly Berlin course on the shamatha and vipashyana sections of Tsongkhapa's Lam-rim chen-mo; this record gathers the vipashyana sections (4–10): basics for vipashyana, mental labeling, the object to be refuted, over- and under-refutation, conventional phenomena and the Gelug Prasangika two truths.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 5: Mental Labeling & Individual Characteristic Marks ↗ · Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 6: The Object to Be Refuted & Over-refutation ↗ · Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 7: Refutation of the Over-refutation of the Object to Be Refuted ↗ · Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 8: Not Losing the Assertion of Conventional Phenomena ↗ · Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 9: Under-refutation of the Object to Be Refuted ↗ · Shamatha & Vipashyana – Section 10: Gelug Prasangika Assertion of the Two Truths ↗ · Audio course index ↗

Gelug

A Letter of Practical Advice on Sutra and Tantra – Section 9: Emptiness Meditation ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Root text by Je Tsongkhapa · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · 2009 · English · FreeSection 9 of Berzin's weekly Berlin course on Tsongkhapa's Letter of Practical Advice on Sutra and Tantra: voidness in sutra and tantra, self- and other-voidness, and the "neither one nor many" reasoning. Session transcripts plus streaming audio.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.Part 1 — LPA49: Sutra &Tantra Voidness the Same; Self-Voidness & Other-Voidness ↗ · Part 2 — LPA50: Object of Refutation That Is Neither One nor Many ↗ · Part 3 — LPA51: Logic of the Refutation Neither One nor Many ↗ · Part 4 — LPA52: Voidness of Cause and Effect Does Not Negate Functionality ↗ · Part 5 — LPA53: Misconceptions about the Voidness of Cause and Effect ↗ · Section 10: The Two Truths and Mental Labeling ↗ · Part 1 — LPA54: The Two Truths in the Various Tibetan Traditions ↗ · Part 2 — LPA55: Accurate and Inaccurate Mental Labeling ↗ · Part 3 — LPA56: Bases for Labeling, Referent Objects and Referent Things ↗ · Part 4 — LPA57: Mental Labeling and Convenional Truth ↗ · Part 5 — LPA58: Misunderstandings of Voidness ↗ · Part 6 — LPA59: The Connection between Cause and Effect ↗ · Part 7 — LPA60: The Correct View of Voidness and the Two Truths ↗ · Part 8 — LPA61: What Are Needed for Realizing Voidness ↗ · Root text — A Letter of Practical Advice on Sutra and Tantra (Tsongkhapa, tr. Berzin) ↗

Gelug

Emptiness of the Self in the 4 Tenet Systems ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeAudio course recording by Dr. Berzin on how the self and its emptiness are understood in the four Indian Buddhist tenet systems.Streaming audio on the publisher’s page.

Gelug

Explanation of the Heart Sutra (Riga, 2009) and Voidness and Dependent Arising (Riga, 2008) ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Ganden Buddhist Centre, Latvia (archive.org) · 21–23 August 2009; 19 July 2008 · English with Latvian translation · Heart Sutra 4 parts (8 MP3s); Voidness weekend 3 MP3s · FreeA four-session explanation of the Heart Sūtra, and a weekend course on how voidness and dependent arising fit together.Listen or download the MP3 ↗
11 recordings — play or download each MP3Heart Sutra pt 1 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090821 (1:51:03) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 1 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090821_vbr (1:51:03) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 2 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090822_s2 (1:52:06) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 2 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090822_s2_vbr (1:52:06) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 3 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090822_s3 (2:00:26) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 3 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090822_s3_vbr (2:00:26) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 4 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090823_s4 (1:55:03) · MP3 ↗Heart Sutra pt 4 — berzin_heart_sutra_20090823_s4_vbr (1:55:03) · MP3 ↗Voidness & Dependent Arising 2008 — berzin_20080719_voidness_s1 (1:43:39) · MP3 ↗Voidness & Dependent Arising 2008 — berzin_20080719_voidness_s2 (1:35:56) · MP3 ↗Voidness & Dependent Arising 2008 — berzin_20080720_voidness_s3 (1:47:31) · MP3 ↗

Texts

Other Tibetan schools

The Basics for Understanding Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Berlin seminar, January 1995 · Study Buddhism / Berzin Archives · Free English transcriptAn introduction using the five aggregates to distinguish the conventional person from an imagined, independently existing self.

Scholarly / Tibetan Buddhist traditions

Emptiness and Creativity ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Berlin seminar, October 2011 · Study Buddhism / Berzin Archives · Free English transcript

A practical discussion of emptiness and the creative process: examining ideas about the artist, audience and artwork, responding to criticism, and creating with a realistic wish to benefit others.

Gelug

The Gelug Prasangika & Svatantrika Views of Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeDetailed article on how Gelug distinguishes Svatantrika and Prasangika in terms of what establishes the existence of things, and therefore what voidness negates in each.

Gelug

Meditation on Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeFour-part teaching on identifying the "me" to be refuted, its subtler levels and the misconceptions it fuels, ending with the four-point analysis meditation on voidness.Part 1 — Identifying the False “Me” ↗ · Part 2 — Subtler Levels of a False “Me” ↗ · Part 3 — Misconceptions Based on Belief in a False “Me” ↗ · Part 4 — Four-Point Analysis Meditation on Emptiness ↗

Gelug

Voidness Rather Than Emptiness ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeShort article on why Berzin translates shunyata as "voidness".

Gelug

Letter to a Friend – Section 7: Emptiness of the Self & the Aggregates ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Root text by Nagarjuna · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · 2007 · English · FreeSection 7 of Berzin's weekly Berlin course on Nagarjuna's Letter to a Friend: the self as merely labelled on the aggregates, the doctrinally based and automatically arising impossible self, and the voidness of the aggregates. Session transcripts from the audio course.Part 1 — LTF 41: The Self Is Merely Labelled on the Aggregates ↗ · Part 2 — LTF 42: The Doctrinally Based Impossible Self – The 3 Main Characteristics ↗ · Part 3 — LTF 43: The Automatically Arising Impossible Self; the 20 Deluded Outlooks ↗ · Part 4 — LTF 44: More on the Deluded Outlooks; Voidness of the Aggregates ↗ · Part 5 — LTF 45: Origin of the Aggregates; 3 Things Obstructing Liberation ↗ · Part 6 — LTF 46: Perseverance; the 3 Higher Trainings; Mindfulness ↗

Gelug

Emptiness Means Dependent Arising and Vice Versa ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeArticle on Tsongkhapa's insight that voidness means dependent arising and dependent arising means voidness, in the context of Prasangika Madhyamaka.

Gelug

Applying Emptiness When Stuck in Traffic ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreePractical seminar excerpt applying voidness to everyday frustration – deconstructing the appearance of someone as inherently an "idiot" while stuck in traffic.

Gelug

What Is Emptiness? ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeIntroductory article on voidness and the question of whether it is nothingness, in Berzin's presentation.

Gelug

The Buddhist Concept of Reality ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeArticle on the world of appearances our minds create, reality as established by cause and effect, and the relation of both to suffering.

Gelug

The Perfection of Wisdom: Prajnaparamita ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeArticle on far-reaching discriminating awareness (prajnaparamita): the types of discriminating awareness, and voidness in relation to the six perfections.

Gelug

The Four Buddhist Tenet Systems Regarding Illusion ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · November 2002 · English · FreeSeminar on what "like an illusion" means in each tenet system, contrasting how appearances are said to be false or deceptive from Vaibhashika to Prasangika.

Gelug

Cognition of the Two Truths: Gelug Tenet Systems ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeArticle on the type of cognition of the two truths needed to rid ourselves of true causes of suffering, as presented in the Gelug tenet systems.

Gelug

Emptiness Understood by Arhats & Buddhas: 4 Tenet Systems ↗Dr. Alexander Berzin · Study Buddhism (Berzin Archives e.V.) · English · FreeArticle comparing what voidness arhats and Buddhas realize according to the Hinayana and Mahayana tenet systems, and why the Prasangika view holds both must realize the voidness of all phenomena.

Amdo Geshe Jampal Rolwé Lodrö

Texts 1

Gelug (Rimé-leaning) · 1888–1936

Texts

Gelug

The Messenger of Authentic Reasoning: A Letter Initiating the Occasion for Debate Sent from Derge Lhundrup Teng ↗Amdo Geshe Jampal Rolwé Lodrö · Lotsawa House · English (Tibetan original editions linked) · FreeA verse letter inviting scholars to debate, in which Amdo Geshe states his theses on emptiness. He defends phenomena being empty of their own essence alongside a qualified 'other-empty' reading of buddha nature, and the indivisibility of bliss and emptiness, which he calls the fundamental point of Tsongkhapa's lineage. Translated by Adam Pearcey (2018; first published on Lotsawa House 2025), with translator’s introduction.Tibetan text (བོད་ཡིག): ལུགས་གཉིས་ཀྱི་མདུན་ས་ཆེན་པོ་སྡེ་དགེ་ལྷུན་གྲུབ་སྟེང་ནས་ཕྱོགས་ཀྱི་མཁས་པ་རྣམས་ལ་སྤྲིང་བ་རྩོད་པའི་སྐབས་རྣམ་པར་དབྱེ་བའི་ཡི་གེ་ཡང་དག་རིགས་པའི་ཕོ་ཉ། ↗

Ven. Amy Miller

Video 1 · Audio 2

Teachers A–Z: every collection with Ven. Amy Miller

Gelug · FPMT nun and teacher

Video

Audio

Gelug

Empathy, Emptiness and Empowerment in Vulnerable Times (day retreat, 2017) ↗Ven. Amy Miller · Ocean of Compassion (Gyalwa Gyatso) Buddhist Center, FPMT — Internet Archive · 2017-05-06 · English · FreeDay retreat with meditation on responding to cruelty and heartlessness in the world with empathy and the understanding of emptiness.Listen or download the MP3 ↗
4 recordings — play or download each MP3Session 1 — GGBC 2017-05-06 Ven Amy Miller Riding the Wave 1-of-4 (1:16:23) · MP3 ↗Session 2 — GGBC 2017-05-06 Ven Amy Miller Riding the Wave 2-of-4 (52:11) · MP3 ↗Session 3 — GGBC 2017-05-06 Ven Amy Miller Riding the Wave 3-of-4 (1:32:23) · MP3 ↗Session 4 — GGBC 2017-05-06 Ven Amy Miller Riding the Wave 4-of-4 (35:18) · MP3 ↗
Also relevant to Bodhicitta & Mind Training.

Andy Karr

Individual teacher page

Scholarly conversation · Kagyu / Shambhala training

Visit Andy Karr’s page for recordings and sources →

Contemplative Practice, Materialism, and the Buddha Dharma →

Khenchen Appey Rinpoche

Texts 1

Teachers A–Z: every collection with Khenchen Appey Rinpoche

Other Tibetan schools · Sakya

Texts